Damn. We thought we had it covered. Eat right, sleep tight, and exercise at least 30 minutes a day most days of the week. Whether that 30 minutes of exercise consisted of aerobic activity, weight lifting, or a mixture of both didn’t matter; as long as we huffed and puffed for at least a half hour, we were supposed to be good.
That’s what they told us.
Now they say we also need to stand several hours a day. Sure, it sounds ridiculous at first, but the results of a compelling new study show that standing affects the body in a positive way that’s completely different from exercising.
What They Did
Researchers at Maastricht University in the Netherlands noted that a typical office worker, when you combine work time, reality TV time, and porn or game time, spends as much as 10 or 11 hours a day sitting in a chair.
No one thinks this is a good idea. All that literal downtime has been associated with diabetes, poor cardiovascular health, and the kind of muscle flaccidity you see in astronauts who’ve been marooned in space in zero gravity conditions for a year or two.
So what the scientists wanted to see was whether a single bout of daily exercise could make some withdrawals from the bad-health bank account that chronic sitters had been making deposits in for so long.
They had 61 volunteers scoot their chairs over. Some were overweight and some were healthy. Some were fat and some were slim. None exercised regularly. Each completed three separate 4-day sessions of grossly exaggerated lifestyles:
- For the first session, men and women sat for 14 hours a day, interrupted only by trips to the bathroom.
- The second 4-day session substituted 1 hour of sitting with 1 hour of exercising on a stationary bicycle (at a moderate pace). The other 13 hours were spent back in their chairs.
- For the third 4-day session, the participants spent only 8 hours sitting while they stood or strolled around at a moderate pace for 5 or 6 hours.
What They Found
After four days of doing nothing but sitting, insulin resistance went up. So did cholesterol. The subjects also exhibited detrimental changes to the lining of their blood vessels (the endothelial cells), which could of course lead to cardiovascular change.
After the session that included four days of moderate cycling, things looked a bit better. While their insulin sensitivity or cholesterol profiles remained unchanged, the health of their endothelial cells improved.
Here comes the weird part: Four days of mixing sitting and standing or meandering around led to improved insulin sensitivity and cholesterol levels, while the health of their endothelial cells remained unchanged.
See what happened? It took both cycling and standing/strolling to offset the negative effects of all that sitting; cycling “fixed” endothelial cell health and standing/strolling “fixed” cholesterol and insulin resistance.
All that standing/strolling may have had more of a pronounced effect on metabolism because it increases the number of minute but significant muscular contractions made throughout the day to stay upright and moving.
Muscles that are active, even modestly so, burn sugar and thus keep insulin levels steady, and that extra activity might lead to the release of nitric oxide, which rejuvenates endothelial cells.
What This Means to You
The obvious message is to unpeel your butt from your chair. Working out hard for an hour or two does not release you from this obligation. If the only time you’re up and around is during your workout, you’re likely missing a part of the fitness equation.
Increasing the amount of time you spend walking or standing might be easier said than done, though. If you work in an office for a mean little man with a bad toupee and a soup-stained tie, he may not take kindly to you taking long, meandering walks among the jacaranda-tree bordered boulevards near your work place. Fine. But the important thing is to get up off your chair and do something, if only for a few minutes.
For instance, get up at least once every half hour or so and whip out some single-leg Romanian deadlifts, or maybe balance on one leg with your eyes closed for as long as you can; anything that will challenge your balance and activate multiple muscle groups.
Alternately, you might buck up for one of those standing desks, annoying TV ads notwithstanding.
- Duvivier, Bernard, et al. “Reducing sitting time versus adding exercise: differential effects on biomarkers of endothelial dysfunction and metabolic risk.” Scientific Reports, volume 8, Article number: 8657, 05 June, 2018